Duplicate Keys NYC
Where Can I Get Duplicate Keys Made in NYC?
Basics Plus cuts duplicate keys on the spot at three Manhattan storefronts — Upper West Side, Midtown, and Union Square — plus a main shop on 3rd Avenue. Standard house keys, building keys, high-security keys, and custom-cut specialty keys are all cut at the counter and checked in the lock before you leave. Call (347) 549-9077 or walk in during shop hours.
Where to Get a Duplicate Key Cut in Manhattan
You don't need an appointment to duplicate a standard key — bring it to any of the three storefronts and hand it across the counter:
- Basics Plus On Broadway — 2315 Broadway at 83rd Street, New York, NY 10024 (Upper West Side)
- Basics Plus Midtown — 845 2nd Avenue, New York, NY 10017 (Midtown Manhattan)
- Basics Plus Union Square — 121 University Place at 13th Street, New York, NY 10003 (Union Square/Greenwich Village)
- Main shop — 91 3rd Avenue, New York, NY 10003
Shop hours are Monday to Saturday, 8:00am to 7:00pm. Emergency lockouts are covered 24/7 at (347) 549-9077, but for a standard key duplication, walking in during shop hours is the faster route.
What Types of Keys Basics Plus Duplicates
Not every key is the same job, and Basics Plus cuts across the full range:
- Standard house keys — cut on the spot at any of the three counters.
- Building keys — for apartment buildings, co-ops, and office suites.
- High-security keys — Medeco, Mul-T-Lock, and Abloy systems, which use restricted keyways.
- Custom-cut specialty keys — non-standard blanks that a hardware-store kiosk typically can't handle.
Every key is cut in-house and checked in the actual lock before the customer walks out — not just cut to a template and handed over.
High-Security Key Duplication: What to Bring
Standard keys get duplicated immediately at the counter. High-security cylinders — Medeco, Mul-T-Lock, and Abloy — are restricted systems, which means duplicating one requires a key card or building paperwork. This isn't a Basics Plus policy; it's how those key systems are designed, and it's also why they can't be copied at a hardware-store kiosk in the first place. If your building uses one of these systems, bring your key card or ask your building manager for the authorization paperwork before you come to the counter — it saves a second trip.
How Key Duplication Works at Basics Plus
- Bring the key to the counter, or call ahead if you're not sure what type it is.
- A licensed locksmith looks at the key and confirms whether it's a standard cut, a building key, or a restricted high-security key requiring paperwork.
- The key is cut on the spot in the shop.
- The new key is checked in the lock before you leave, so you're not walking out with a key that doesn't turn.
There's no dispatcher and no subcontractor in this process — the person who assesses the key is the person who cuts it.
Why Manhattan Residents Use Basics Plus for Duplicate Keys
- 35+ years in business, serving Manhattan since 1988.
- Three real NYC storefronts, not a call center routing jobs to subcontractors.
- Licensed and certified locksmiths on staff, doing the cutting themselves, not a rotating list of subcontractors.
- Keys are checked in the lock before the customer leaves the counter.
FAQ: Duplicate Keys in NYC
Where can I get duplicate keys made in NYC? At any of the three Basics Plus storefronts — Upper West Side (Broadway at 83rd), Midtown (2nd Avenue), or Union Square (University Place) — or the main shop on 3rd Avenue. Standard keys are cut on the spot during shop hours, Monday to Saturday, 8:00am to 7:00pm.
Can I duplicate a high-security key at a hardware store? No. Medeco, Mul-T-Lock, and Abloy keys use restricted keyways, which is why kiosks can't copy them. Basics Plus can cut these, but you'll need to bring a key card or building paperwork.
Do I need an appointment to duplicate a key? No appointment is needed for a standard key — walk into any of the three shops during hours and it's cut at the counter. High-security keys may take a little longer since the locksmith has to verify your paperwork first.
What's the difference between duplicating a key and rekeying a lock? Duplicating a key makes a working copy of a key you already have. Rekeying changes the pins inside the lock itself so old keys — including any copies you don't know about — stop working. If you're worried about who might have a copy of your key, rekeying is the better fit; see our apartment rekeying page for that process.
How much does it cost to duplicate a key in NYC? Cost depends on the type of key — a standard house key is a different job than a restricted high-security key requiring building paperwork, or a custom-cut specialty blank. Basics Plus quotes the price at the counter before cutting anything, so call (347) 549-9077 or stop by any shop with your key for a straight number.
Can Basics Plus cut a key for a co-op or building system? Yes. Building keys and master key systems are part of the regular counter work at all three storefronts. If your building uses a restricted high-security system, bring your key card or ask your managing agent for the required paperwork.