Key Cutting NYC
H1: Where Can You Get Key Cutting Done in NYC?
Basics Plus cuts keys on the spot at three real Manhattan storefronts — Union Square, the Upper West Side, and Midtown — plus a main shop on 3rd Avenue. Standard house keys, building keys, high-security keys, and custom-cut specialty keys are all cut in-shop and checked in the lock before you leave. Call (347) 549-9077 or walk in Mon–Sat, 8am–7pm.
A Real Shop, Not a Kiosk
A hardware-store kiosk cuts a blank and hands it back. Basics Plus has run storefront locksmith shops in Manhattan since 1988 — you hand your key across the counter to the person doing the cutting, and that person checks the new key in the actual lock before you walk out. That last step matters most on prewar apartment doors, where a key that looks right on a blank can still bind in an old cylinder.
What Keys We Cut
- Standard house and building keys — cut on the spot, no appointment needed for a straightforward duplicate.
- High-security keys — Medeco, Mul-T-Lock, and Abloy restricted keyways. These can't be duplicated at a hardware-store kiosk; bring your key card or building paperwork if your system requires one.
- Custom-cut specialty keys — non-standard blanks and older profiles that a general hardware counter won't stock.
- Whole-key and lock work together — if a key won't cut cleanly because the cylinder itself is worn, the same counter handles rekeying or lock installation, so you're not sent somewhere else mid-visit.
High-Security Keys: What to Bring
Restricted keyways like Medeco, Mul-T-Lock, and Abloy exist specifically so a copy can't be made without authorization. If your building or landlord issued you a key card, bring it to the counter — that's what lets us cut a duplicate on a restricted system. If you're not sure whether your key is a restricted profile, bring the key itself; a locksmith at any of the three shops can tell you on sight.
Where to Walk In
| Location | Address | Neighborhood |
|---|---|---|
| Basics Plus On Broadway | 2315 Broadway at 83rd Street, New York, NY 10024 | Upper West Side |
| Basics Plus Midtown | 845 2nd Avenue, New York, NY 10017 | Midtown Manhattan |
| Basics Plus Union Square | 121 University Place at 13th Street, New York, NY 10003 | Union Square / Greenwich Village |
| Main shop | 91 3rd Avenue, New York, NY 10003 | — |
Shop hours are Monday to Saturday, 8:00am to 7:00pm. Emergency lockouts are covered 24/7, but routine key cutting is a walk-in, in-shop job during those hours.
How It Works at the Counter
- You bring the key or describe the lock. Standard duplicates just need the original key; high-security keys need your key card or building paperwork.
- A licensed locksmith cuts it on the spot — no mail-in, no waiting on a third party.
- The new key is checked in the lock before you leave. If it doesn't turn smoothly, it gets adjusted or re-cut right there, not after you've walked home and found out.
- You hear the price before anything's cut. Basics Plus quotes transparently, with no hidden charges.
Why Manhattan Residents Use Basics Plus for Key Cutting
- 35+ years in business, serving Manhattan since 1988.
- Three real NYC storefronts — not a call center or a kiosk contractor.
- Licensed and certified locksmiths on staff, doing the cutting themselves, not routing it to a subcontractor.
- Transparent pricing, quoted before any work begins.
- Every key checked in the lock before the customer leaves the counter.
FAQ
Where can I get key cutting done in NYC? Basics Plus cuts keys in-shop at three storefronts — Union Square/Greenwich Village, the Upper West Side, and Midtown Manhattan — plus a main shop on 3rd Avenue, Mon–Sat 8am–7pm. Call (347) 549-9077 or walk in with the key.
Do you cut high-security keys like Medeco or Mul-T-Lock? Yes. Medeco, Mul-T-Lock, and Abloy restricted keys are cut in-shop; bring your key card or building paperwork since these systems can't be duplicated at a hardware-store kiosk.
Do I need an appointment for key cutting? No — standard house and building keys are walk-in, cut on the spot during shop hours. High-security keys follow the same walk-in process as long as you bring the required authorization.
How much does key cutting cost in NYC? It depends on the type of key. Standard duplicates are a different job than a restricted high-security cylinder key or a custom-cut specialty blank — Basics Plus quotes the price before cutting anything, so call (347) 549-9077 with the key type for a straight number.
Can you cut a key for a prewar apartment lock? Yes. Basics Plus has cut keys for Manhattan's older mortise and high-security cylinders since 1988, including Segal, Medeco, and Mul-T-Lock hardware common in prewar buildings.
What if the new key doesn't turn smoothly? Every key is checked in the actual lock before you leave the counter. If it doesn't turn right, it's adjusted or re-cut on the spot.