Lock Rekeying Service NYC
Where Can You Get Lock Rekeying Service in NYC?
Basics Plus provides lock rekeying service across Manhattan from three real storefronts — Upper West Side, Midtown, and Union Square/Greenwich Village — plus a main shop on 3rd Avenue. Licensed staff swap the pins inside your existing cylinder, cut new keys on the spot, and quote the price before starting. Most apartments are finished in a single visit. Call (347) 549-9077.
What "Rekeying" Actually Means
Rekeying keeps the lock you already have. Basics Plus takes out the cylinder, swaps the small pins inside to a new combination, and cuts a fresh set of keys to match. The lock body, the face plate, and the door itself stay exactly as they are — only the pin combination changes. Every key that used to open the door stops working the moment the job is done.
This is different from replacing the hardware entirely. Rekeying is usually the faster of the two options, and it keeps the lock your building or co-op board already approved — which matters in Manhattan buildings with house rules about hardware changes.
Is Lock Rekeying Service Right for You, or Do You Need a Replacement?
Nine times out of ten in a Manhattan apartment, rekeying — not replacing — is the right call, because the hardware on the door is usually fine. The problem is who still holds a key to it. Basics Plus rekeys locks for:
- New move-ins — the last tenant, their friends, or anyone who borrowed a key over the years may still have one.
- Roommate turnover — when someone leaves the lease, changing the pins is cleaner than asking for every copy back.
- Lost or stolen keys — a bag taken on the subway often holds both a key and an address; rekeying makes the missing key useless.
- Break-ups — quiet, quick, no drama at the door.
- Contractors and service workers — after painters, movers, cleaners, or dog walkers had a copy, resetting the lock puts control back in one set of hands.
- Tenant turnover for landlords and managing agents — Basics Plus handles single units and whole floors, one key per door or one key for all.
When the cylinder is worn, the key drags, the deadbolt was forced, or there's no deadbolt at all, replacement — not rekeying — is the better job, and Basics Plus will tell you which one your door actually needs before quoting anything.
Built for the Locks Manhattan Actually Has
Manhattan apartment doors are their own category, and Basics Plus keeps the pins, blanks, and tools for all of it:
- Pre-war and mortise cylinders — old brass cylinders are rekeyable far more often than people expect; if one is past saving, the shop says so before starting.
- Segal, Medeco, and Mul-T-Lock cylinders — common on NYC apartment doors and rekeyable, though high-security cylinders use restricted keys, so bring your key card or paperwork if your building requires one.
- Co-op and condo hardware — locks a building board has already approved stay in place; rekeying resets who can open the door without touching the hardware itself.
How the Visit Works
You describe the door, lock, or building — by phone, through the contact form, or standing at the counter with a key in hand. A licensed locksmith looks at the cylinder, tells you whether it's a rekey or a replacement, and quotes the price before anything is touched. Most apartment rekeys are finished in a single visit, either at your door or over the counter at one of the three shops.
Where to Get It Done
Basics Plus operates lock rekeying service from three real Manhattan storefronts, plus a main shop:
- Basics Plus On Broadway — 2315 Broadway at 83rd Street, New York, NY 10024 (Upper West Side)
- Basics Plus Midtown — 845 2nd Avenue, New York, NY 10017 (Midtown Manhattan)
- Basics Plus Union Square — 121 University Place at 13th Street, New York, NY 10003 (Union Square/Greenwich Village)
- Main shop — 91 3rd Avenue, New York, NY 10003
Shop hours are Monday to Saturday, 8:00am to 7:00pm. If you're locked out or need same-day service, call — someone answers 24/7 for lockouts.
Why Manhattan Residents Use Basics Plus for Rekeying
- 35+ years in business, serving Manhattan since 1988.
- Three real NYC storefronts — not a call center routing jobs to subcontractors.
- Licensed staff on site who cut the keys and swap the pins themselves.
- Transparent pricing — quoted before any work begins, with no hidden charges.
FAQ
What is a lock rekeying service in NYC? It's a locksmith visit where the existing lock cylinder is opened, the internal pins are swapped to a new combination, and fresh keys are cut to match. The lock, face plate, and door stay the same — only the old keys stop working. Basics Plus does this on the spot at any of its three Manhattan shops or at your door.
How is rekeying different from changing the whole lock? Rekeying reuses your current cylinder and only changes which keys open it. Replacing swaps in new hardware entirely. Basics Plus recommends replacement only when the cylinder is worn, the key drags, the deadbolt was forced, or there's no deadbolt at all.
How long does a lock rekeying service take in NYC? Most Manhattan apartments are finished in a single visit, whether it happens at your door or over the counter at one of the three shops.
Can pre-war or high-security locks be rekeyed? Yes. Pre-war and mortise cylinders are rekeyable far more often than people expect, and Segal, Medeco, and Mul-T-Lock cylinders are also rekeyable — high-security cylinders just require a key card or building paperwork since they use restricted keys.
Do I need an appointment, or can I walk in? You can call, use the contact form, or walk into any of the three storefronts with a key in hand. A licensed locksmith assesses the job and gives you a price before starting.
What if my building requires a specific lock brand? Basics Plus keeps pins, blanks, and tools for the cylinders common in NYC co-ops and condos, including Segal, Medeco, and Mul-T-Lock, so the hardware your board already approved usually stays exactly as it is.